You are browsing the archive for Superfunds.

Ottawa Illinois: A Superfund Site and Home to the Radium Girls

January 24, 2011 in Superfunds, Uncategorized

PhotobucketPhotobucket

When the first wristwatches were being made for WW1 and WW2, it was decided that glow in the dark dials would be very useful. The new wonder substance at the time was a radioactive element called radium. Given the huge lack of knowledge of the effects of radiation, radium was used for everything from pepping up soft drinks to bathing in for therapeutic effects. [So typical of the enthusiasm of new technologies and unknown materials, even today.  I remember touring the bath houses in Hot Springs and learning to my horror that among the treatments at the turn of the last century were mercury rubs. It's a wonder that the entire population of the USA is not genetically mutated beyond repair--perhaps we are and the rest of the world is too kind to let us know.  That could certainly explain a lot.]

**********************************************************************

Photobucket

The Radium Girls, who were they?

In 1922 The Radium Dial Company (RDC) moved from Peru, Illinois to a former high school building in Ottawa. The company employed hundreds of young women who painted watch dials using a paint called “Luna” for watch maker Westclox.  RDC went out of business in 1936, two years after the company’s president, Joseph Kelly Sr., left to start a competing company, Luminous Processes Inc., a few blocks away.

Nationwide there were an estimated 4,000 workers who were affected. I’m sure in my research of Superfund sites that I’ll come across more towns that were (and still are) affected by the carelessness from almost 100 years ago. My research on Radium Girls indicates that there are several other radium “hot spots” in the USA.  It has been reported that as part of their training the young women were encouraged to make a fine point on their brushes by rolling the tips on their tongues before dipping them in the radium-laced paint.  Their bosses told them not to worry, that it would just make their cheeks rosy.  The women at Radium Dial sometimes even painted their teeth and turned out the lights for a joke. By 1925, the company was aware of the toxic radiation workers were exposed to, but it did not inform the young women.  Instead, the company continued to encourage its female workers to run their paintbrushes through their lips to get a sharper point for neater work. [This is from court records that the girls later filed.]

Many of the Radium Girls ended up with tumors bulging from their jaws and their teeth falling out. Many of them died from cancer. When women started becoming sick, company doctors said they had syphilis, typhus and pneumonia. By 1934, seven women called “The Society of the Living Dead” began a legal battle with the company. The Depression was gripping the country, and jobs were scarce. There was little public support for the women just as there is little public support for many workers today in the USA.

Radium exposure caused cancer that left the women’s bones honeycombed. During the course of their illnesses, some had amputations. Some had teeth extracted and chunks of their jawbones also came out. Some developed large tumors on their jaws or legs where radium settled. Death was painful. The buildings where the girls worker were destroyed in 1969 and 1984 but the radium was scattered and it remains in Ottawa.  In 1997 a study conducted by Northern Illinois documented an above-average cancer rat for the area. But no follow-up study has been done.

Officials at the Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection have found contamination — including in apartment buildings that are former dial painting studios — in Waterbury, Bristol, New Haven and other towns. Cleanup on a radium-laced landfill in Glen Ridge, N.J. — one of four sites that had to be dealt with in that state began in 1998. In all, the EPA expects to spend more than $144 million for radium cleanup in New Jersey and New York, with detoxification begun in West Orange and Orange, site of the now-defunct U.S. Radium Co. A site in Montclair, N.J., is now free of radium as is the site of the former Radium Chemical Co. in New York’s borough of Queen according to reports from EPA officials.

*********************************************************************

Cleaning up Radium

In Ottawa, Federal money to clean up four remaining Superfund sites laced with radium has run out.Even after the Radium Dial Co. building was demolished, people took bricks from the site to reuse and desks from the factory were donated to area schools, spreading the contamination.

In the 1970s, when federal Superfund cleanup money started coming to the community, the radium hot spots were gradually remediated. Today, the Environmental Protection Agency continues to monitor one site at the edge of town that could cost $80 million to clean up.  SOURCE [The other sources include data gathered from the Environmental Protection Agency site linked below as well as Wikipedia.]

Go HERE to read EPA work as the agency continues to clean up and remediate the Ottawa Radium sites. Be sure to read the March 2010 report. Since there is not enough money left.  This is the solution to be followed.

************************************************************************

In Conclusion

Please remember the pain and early deaths of the Radium Girls.  Few of them ever made it past the age of 30 and they died a horrible, painful disfiguring death.  Please remember that the Radium contamination lives on–almost a 100 years later.  Please remember that there are 1,280 sites like this and worse that have been identified with other types of contamination all over the USA.  And even more importantly, remember that hundreds more are in the making each year.  The only way to stop such mayhem is with regulation.

The path seems to be a narrow one here:  either people cling to their right-wing ideology of the “free” market, or you make room for some regulations to protect citizens like the Radium Girls.

Proclaim the Queen!

    Super Fund Sites in the USA

    January 24, 2011 in Superfunds

    I’ve decided to create a new category for the Queen site:  SUPERFUNDS.  This is my second posting to that category. The first post was February 27, 2009. I filed that story under Corporations and Environment:  Quapaw Oklahoma–what a town in the USA looks like when a mining company is finished with it.
    I’ll move it to the new SUPERFUNDS category as Quapaw is a Superfund site here in the USA.

    Superfund is the common name for the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980 (CERCLA), a United States federal law designed to clean up sites contaminated with hazardous substances.

    The law authorized the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to identify parties responsible for contamination of sites and compel the parties to clean up the sites. Where responsible parties cannot be found, the Agency is authorized to clean up sites itself, using a special trust fund.

    How to you like ‘them apples’?  “Where responsible parties cannot be found. . . You see that’s what corporations do.  They come into communities and after they have mined all the ore, or coal, or finished with their manufacturing activities, they disappear or morph into some other corporation, and they leave their toxic waste behind for the taxpayers to clean up and/or to haggle for years with corporate lawyers to get the corporation to pay for the damage they have done.  In the meantime, as in the case of Quapaw and other communities, the citizens die of cancer after years of exposure to the toxins in their environment left by the corporation.  The situation is even worse in emerging nations.

    **********************************************************************

    Sometimes these companies work with crooked politicians to set things up legally so that they can worm out of the legal responsibility for cleaning up their mess several years down the line.  That is exactly the kind of deal that it appears that Harold Simmons may have  struck with Rick Perry and the Republican Texas Legislature. (Prove me wrong and I’ll be more than happy to eat crow on this one.)

    You see, Dallas billionaire Harold Simmons was recently given a license to operate a site out in West Texas to store “hot” nuclear waste that will remain “hot” for several generations.

    In 15 years the license reverts back to the taxpayers of Texas.  If you don’t get it, read on:  These means that after Harold Simmons has reaped the benefits of all the profits from this deal the taxpayers will have the responsibility and the expense of babysitting this hazardous waste for at least 100 years if not forever.

    If the leaders of the government in Texas represented the people and our future generations as they should, instead of their own campaign funds that the live off of, the business plan for Mr Simmons would set aside each month money to be paid to a special trust account for baby-sitting this toxic waste long after Mr. Simmons is dead.

    **********************************************************************

    The Map Below is current as of March 2010.  Red equals current; green equals cleaned up; yellow indicates proposed site. As of November 29, 2010, there are currently 1,280 sites listed on the National Priority List, an additional 347 have been de-listed, and 62 new sites have been proposed.

    File:Superfund sites.svg

    Proclaim the Queen!

      Quapaw Oklahoma–what a town in the USA looks like when a mining company is finished with it.

      February 27, 2009 in Corporations, Environment, Superfunds

      From Zen Chronicles of the Mother Road – [a tale by the Queen and her friends]

      Background
      In May of 2007, I took a road trip with five other friends over the old Route 66 from Chicago to Albuquerque.  Quapaw Oklahoma is on that path.  We went through it in somewhat of a rush and I don’t remember a lot about the first time I went through Quapaw.  However, in August of 2007 I took a road trip with my dog Bubbles up to that northeastern part of Oklahoma because I wanted to visit and photograph  some totems in Foyil Oklahoma. [Foyil was a bit off our path and I had begged my friends to stop, but we were on a mission to get to Oklahoma City so we did not.]  It was on this return trip that I learned more of the history of Quapaw.

      In fact, this summer I’ve been thinking about traveling around the USA and doing a book that records the aftermath of American towns and their landscapes after mining companies finish up with them.  Too bad the arts didn’t get any money in the stimulus–otherwise I could apply for a grant.

      *********************************************

      THE STORY OF QUAPAW, OKLAHOMA

      Quapaw is a very charming and pretty town, in spite of the fact that many of the buildings are boarded up as they are in most of the small towns along Route 66. Several of the buildings, such as the one below have lovely murals painted on them–that’s another book too, photographs of all the interesting murals painting on the exterior walls of deserted and forgotten buildings in the USA.

      Miningmural-1.jpg picture by eeberry

      As you can see from the mural, mining was once very central to the community of Quapaw.  Below is a photo I took of that same building from a different angle.

      Greenbldg-1.jpg picture by eeberry

      Then I saw sign on another building that raised my curiosity.  It carried a warning for children to not play on “chat piles”.  The warning made no sense to me at the time as I had no idea as to what a chat pile was.  [At the time I thought it might refer to chat rooms on computers and was a warning against child predators who often frequent those sites.]  It was only after I got home and researched the topic that I learned what chat piles are.

      Chatpiles-1-1.jpg picture by eeberry

      Chat piles are mining tailings that are the toxic residue that is left behind by the mining process. The mining industry has a very bad history world wide of the damages that it does to the environment and the toxic waste that it irresponsibly leaves behind for others to clean up. The situation at Quapaw is no exception.

      I’ve read about tailings but I don’t remember seeing any up close until my recent visit to Quapaw. I assume they will vary in color according to the mineral that has been mined. Some of ones in Quapaw are bright golden in color. They look quite like huge piles of sand—thus they would be especially inviting to small children. In size, the ones at Quapaw are about the size of a two or three story building with bases of perhaps up to a city block. They are not small, and they are numerous. I saw no less that five of these piles right only a few blocks from the downtown area of Quapaw.

      ***********************************************

      Mining has destroyed the land and water and poisoned the people who live in the Tar Creek area of Quapaw. These large piles of leftover mining tailings, called chat piles, are in close proximity to local residences and school yards. They are contaminated with heavy metals that pose a threat to the children who play on them. When the wind blows, the contaminated dust from the mining tailings fills the homes of the residents. Those living around Tar Creek are exposed to large amounts of lead, zinc and cadmium from the watershed and the soil in the residential area.

      Many of the chat piles remain looming over the community of Quapaw with no plan to have them removed. There has been some progress over the past 25 years. Since 1983 the EPA has plugged 83 wells, reducing contaminants reaching the Roubideax aquifer, the main water supply for the community.

      **************************************************

      As typical of the history of mining companies, even today, they are notorious for taking advantage of indigenous people. In the 1870s the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) illegitimately sold land belonging to the Quapaw tribe to mining companies (9). The tribe was not willing to sell the land. However, the transactions proceeded as the BIA declared opposing tribal members incompetent and sold the land to the mining companies. Lead and zinc mining persisted from 1891 to 1970. The BIA also required the mining companies to leave the hazardous chat on site because it would “be of economic value to the tribe.

      **************************************************

      Following is a photo [not taken by the Queen] from “The Results of Mining at Tar Creek”- Environmental case Study by NRE 392 Group 5.  From that study: Those living around Tar Creek are exposed to large amounts of lead, zinc, and cadmium from the watershed and the soil in residential areas. The Tar Creek area has been on the National Priorities List (NPL) for 20 years and has a rating of 58.15 (2003); the minimum score required to be put on the List is only 28.5. Tar Creek is highly toxic and, for all intents and purposes, dead. The fish have disappeared from the creek, which has had a significant impact on the lifestyle of the Native Americans in the area. The banks of the creek are a sickening orange color and the groundwater has also been affected by acid water from the abandoned mines.

      **************************************************

      Here is my dog Bubbles sniffing out an ancient stretch of the “sidewalk road.” In 1926, this surviving stretch of the original Route 66 nine feet wide—just wide enough to allow passage for a Moon Roadster. (Moon Motor Car was a United States automobile company based in St Louis from 1905 to 1930.)  Somehow, when we were leaving Quapaw, Bubbles and I took a wrong turn.  I think this stretch of road was about 30 miles long , but it seemed like 100 miles and it was totally deserted.

      Traveling along Route 66 is like going on an archeological expedition, digging into the dust of the past as well as the tenacity of the present for survival in America.  I recommend it.  There is nothing quite like a first hand glimpse into what has happened to our nation.

      bubblesandtheroad-1.jpg picture by eeberry

      Proclaim the Queen!